Skip to content

History talk will focus on grisly hanging case

Be the first to share!
By Fiona Reid
History talk will focus on grisly hanging case

IN May 1868, Robert Colvin Smith from Eaglesfield was hanged for murder at the old Buccleuch Street Prison in Dumfries.

And the case, sometimes referred to the as The Annandale Murder, will now feature as the first ‘gripping’ talk of 2023 in Annan the History Town’s winter programme.

Explaining more, Kathleen Cronie, who is organising this week’s free event and is also the founder of Mostly Ghostly, said: “The case of Robert Smith first captured my attention as a child visiting Dumfries Museum in the 1980s, and has fascinated me ever since. During that visit, I had the opportunity to view Smith’s death mask, pictured, an image that has never left me, and have since conducted a wealth of research into the story, the lives of those involved and the powerful impact his heinous crimes had on the local community.

“This year marks the 155th anniversary of those crimes, and Smith’s subsequent execution — the last public hanging in Scotland — and we aim to offer a unique insight that will inspire guests to discover more about their local history.”

Robert, a 19-year-old farm labourer, murdered Thomasina Scott near Cummertrees. She was just nine-years-old and had been running an errand for her mother, when heavy rain caused her to seek shelter at the home of Jane Crichton. It was there she encountered Robert Smith, who offered to accompany her on the road to Annan. The last person to see Thomasina with Smith was a witness named Thomson, who identified her walking near the murder scene. Smith robbed the child, before raping and strangling her in the Croftshead Wood. He then attempted to murder Mrs Crichton, for fear she could implicate him in Thomasina’s death.

Following the murder, Smith made no real attempt to hide his tracks. The police found him at a lodging house in Dumfries, and he was arrested, tried and found guilty. Smith admitted his crimes in full and he was sentenced to death by public execution.

Smith kept a calm demeanour throughout most of his imprisonment, finding solace in religious studies and making his peace with God.

Kathleen said: “I don’t think any of us can imagine facing a crowd of people awaiting our deaths; the formalities prior to the act, meeting your own executioner and catching the first glimpse of the dreaded gallows.

“Robert Smith, however, seemed to accept his fate and was ready to meet it.”

At the time, a Bill was being passed in Parliament to end the macabre spectacle of public hangings, and some efforts were made to hold the hanging in private, however it was found to be impossible.

Witnessed by a crowd of around 600, he met his maker on Tuesday, May 12 1868. Hangman Thomas Askern assisted Smith to the fatal drop. Before drawing the bolt, Askern had to make some last-minute adjustments, adding to the day’s tensions. Death was by no means swift; due to a misplaced rope, Smith’s convulsions, thankfully screened from view, continued for nine minutes before he died.

Mostly Ghostly members have previously given talks on the story at the Festival of Museums and for various community groups. In addition, they developed and run a tour entitled Deadly Dumfries that guides guests to key locations linked with this landmark case.

Team member John Hill said: “Research into Smith’s case has been ongoing, with visits to the National Records Office in Edinburgh, Dumfries Ewart Library and Dumfries Museum. Over the years, we have learned a lot about the story, gathering compelling information, which will form the basis of our talk.

“It will be interesting to gauge guests’ views, and we are hopeful that some of those attending may provide further insights.”

Summing up, Kathleen added: “We look forward to welcoming our guests next week, and are proud to be working with Annan the History Town to deliver what we aim to be a highly engaging and thought-provoking talk.

“We never forget that real people were affected by these ghastly events, the consequences of which left an indelible mark on the local communities around Annan, and our accounts will be underpinned, as always, with sensitivity and respect.”

It takes place on Tuesday at 7.30 pm at Annan Old Parish Church Hall.

Annan and Eskdale, Front

15th Jun

Chapelcross land purchase update

By Fiona Reid | DNG24