Stories from the last 7 days
Moffat, the new pie and mash capital of Scotland? Escaped alpaca caught by police Public enquiry to consider Whitesands flood scheme Gala season is go She’s got the golden touch Car chase motorist jailed Plucky Terri in abseil fundraiser Break in at pub Region stands with Manchester Elaine is new leader Fireraising at flat Twins get race honour Home victory for Bogie Palliative care consultation Party queen Bella still going strong at 95 Grandad’s recipe sees butcher made haggis king Home improvements firm enters liquidation Task force to tackle ‘death trap’ factory Couple celebrate both getting top Scout honours DJ beats the Bard in civic pride contest Music centres join forces to offer 5 star tuition First look at Butler film shot in region Corinne enjoys life on the ocean waves Banker delivers Duncan lecture Sisters set to launch Glasgow’s Race for Life Dumfries display for ghostly war horses Police probe ‘unusual’ theft of car bonnets Carmichael commits to Queens Donations for Dean Harry Otter and the forestry worker Building society to close Dumfries branch Stuart is Langholm Cornet Drop in voters UPDATE: Dumfries and Galloway NHS hit in cyber attack Flower tub is a terror threat, say police Debut show for song cycle choir Crowdfunding push for fountain makeover Tattie scones are tops in Scotland Dad plans charity match for ‘special cause’ More ‘common sense’ needed in planning, says trader Posties in triple peak fundraiser Gala debut for fun run Finding out about fosteringSearch all stories »




Newsdesk: 01461 202 417 | Search
Change Language:

Read online with DnG Digital

Subscribe now to read all your favourite newspapers online

Yes or no to Indy Ref 2?

Section:  Annan and Eskdale, Dumfries and West, Lockerbie and Lochmaben, Moffat  | Tags: ,

FIRST Minister Nicola Sturgeon this week set the wheels in motion for a second vote on Scottish Independence.

FLOODS gretna BA 2 *** Local Caption *** FLOODS gretna BA 2


And her announcement has been met with a mixed reaction from the public and politicians in Dumfries and Galloway.

Aaron Robinson, who has lived in Dumfries for four years after moving from Newcastle, is perplexed at the timing of a second referendum.

He said: “I hate the fact another Indy Ref might take place. Why say it’s a ‘once in a lifetime’ vote, and then announce they’re doing it again? They must’ve skipped a generation that we weren’t aware of.”

Christine Hughes, also from England, but now living in Moffat disagrees, however.

She said: “Well, I am English and have only lived in Scotland for just over 12 months, so maybe my opinion isn’t valid. But I can understand Scotland wanting independence, and will vote Yes if I am still living in Scotland when the indy ref date is set.”

Alasdair Macrae from Annan views another referendum as a second bite of the cherry that he never though Scotland would have this early.

He said: “In 2014, I don’t think anyone thought of another referendum so soon. Because of Brexit we now have to seek a path for what country we want Scotland to be.”

On the other hand, Will Little, of Dumfries, has compiled a list of ‘once in a generation events’.

He said: “The Olympic Games, The FIFA World Cup, Robbie Williams leaving Take That, Bon Jovi doing a farewell tour, a Scottish Independence Referendum.

“Another perfect distraction created by the SNP Government in their ten year reign. Never mind the state of our local services, schools, police force, or NHS – here’s an argument that will divide families, workplaces and the entire country again.

“ Agreeing with him is Deborah MacBeth, of Beattock.

She said: “No means no. So much for all the hype last time about once in a generation! Time must fly by on Planet SNP.

“Give up and let the country stay united and move on.”

And Nicola Tattersall, of Lockerbie, added: “It doesn’t make sense! She wants Scotland to be independent but still be part of the EU – I wouldn’t call that being independent really!

“And another thing, what if the votes go the other way this time and we do get independence….what happens next: are the ‘no’ voters going to spit their dummy out like the ‘yes’ voters did the first time round? We’ll be going round in circles.”

Meanwhile, Dumfries based author and charity worker Mark Frankland is delighted at the prospect of a second referendum.

He said: “I’m absolutely delighted at the news of a second Indy Ref, but annoyed at a lot of the comments about it. “Some say that the last Indy Ref was awful and divisive, but that wasn’t my experience at all.

Myself and others seen it as a brilliant event, that got people inspired and out of the house.

“It was very clearly stated in the SNP’s manifesto that leaving the EU would give a mandate for another Indy Ref, and the promises made as part of ‘The Vow’ in regards to devolutionary powers have not been kept.”

Paul Geddes, Dumfries, agrees there have been broken promises, and said: “I think it’s only fair to have a second referendum. Normally I’m all for the vote of the people being final but in the aftermath of the first Indy Ref, we have had Westminster break several promises to the Scottish people. Combine the break away from Europe and a large Scottish majority wishing to stay in, It’s only fair that it should go to vote again.”

Share this story:
This story hasn't been shared yet.
Comments/editorial complaints